Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC

Edwin

2 months ago

I’ve lived in NY and been back countless times, and somehow this was my first visit to Gallagher’s. No idea how I waited this long. The steaks were seriously impressive. Both the tomahawk and the strip loin came out perfectly charred on the outside, tender and juicy inside, exactly what you hope for at a classic steakhouse. Easily one of the top 10 steaks I’ve ever had. That deep, smoky crust with the rich beefy flavor… so good. The bacon was decent, personally I’d love it a bit thicker but it still hit the spot. The sides were solid and generous, nothing flashy, just dependable and well done. Service was surprisingly warm and attentive, honestly better than some other old-school spots around town. The whole experience just felt right. My only regret is not discovering this place sooner. Definitely coming back.

Lyle Gadin

2 months ago

Gallagher’s was a great steakhouse experience. We just flew in and wanted to find a steakhouse in Manhattan. When we arrived we were warmly greeted (we had a reservation). The staff was attentive and our waiter, Mr. Nicholas, was fantastic. We ordered: Appetizers - Crab cake (you get one giant one per order), was awesome. Great flavor and a ton of crab. Calamari - tender and lightly breaded, and a wedge salad with blue cheese - delicious. Entrees- Rib Steak, medium rare - cooked perfectly and seasoned just right. Great char and incredibly tender., with sides of Mac and cheese and garlic fried green beans (this was the best side dish). It was a pricier dinner, but for the experience, quality of food, and the ambiance of a great Manhattan, New York restaurant - it was well worth it. I would highly recommend Gallagher’s, what a great dinner experience and service.

Melissa C

2 months ago

We celebrated my sister’s 39th birthday here, and it was absolutely fantastic from start to finish. The shrimp cocktail was incredibly fresh and flavorful — the perfect way to kick off the evening. The filet was cooked to perfection, tender and full of flavor, and the asparagus was seasoned beautifully and complemented the meal perfectly. To top it all off, the birthday desserts were such a special touch and made the celebration even more memorable. The entire experience felt celebratory and elevated. We couldn’t have chosen a better place to celebrate — highly recommend for a special occasion!