Mavericks Montauk

Licelife

9 months ago

We were celebrating our anniversary here and it was amazing! They gave us prosecco to start which was very thoughtful of them, our server was very kind and helpful with our questions. The bread was fluffy and warm, the steak was cooked to perfection. We also got the potato gratin that could use a bit of seasoning, and there was a little mistake with the order because we didn’t order the broccoli but the manager told us we can keep them. We tried the broccoli and honestly it was really good! Great hospitality and food!

Margaret Watt

8 months ago

Was delighted by the meal and experience I recently had at Mavericks. We had been shopping earlier in the day, and a very lovely shop attendant mentioned she worked at Mavericks and recommended we try it! We celebrated our wedding anniversary and dined outside, with a lovely view of the water. The service was attentive, and the cocktails and food delicious and thoughtfully prepared. We started with the Roasted Amagansett Beet Salad (perfectly roasted beets!), and had the lobster radiatori (pictured) and NY Strip. Will definitely be returning.

Nitinun Punprapai

9 months ago

We had a pleasant experience overall with the service—staff were friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was very nice. However, we felt that the food quality didn’t quite match the price. We started with the Tuna Tartare, but unfortunately, the tuna wasn’t fresh and had a strong fishy smell, so we had to send it back. We then ordered the roasted chicken ($45), which was served undercooked. The rest of the dishes were just okay—not bad, but not quite what we expected given the pricing. The pasta had a sour flavor, and the mocktail was also quite sour, so the overall flavor profile didn’t suit our taste. We appreciate the great service, but hope the kitchen can make some improvements.